Why Torque Matters
Proper bolt tightening creates sufficient preload (clamping force) to hold joints together under operating loads. Too little torque — joint leaks or separates. Too much torque — bolt yields, strips threads, or fractures.
The relationship between torque and preload depends on thread friction, under-head friction, thread pitch, and bolt diameter.
Torque-Tension Relationship
The standard short-form equation:
Where:
- T = torque (N·m)
- K = nut factor (dimensionless, accounts for friction)
- D = nominal bolt diameter (m or mm — use consistent units)
- F = preload/bolt tension (N or kN)
Detailed Torque Formula (Long Form)
For more accuracy, break torque into three components:
Where:
- P = thread pitch (mm/rev)
- µt = thread coefficient of friction (0.10-0.20 for lubricated; 0.15-0.25 dry)
- rt = effective thread radius ≈ (D − P/2)/2
- α/2 = half thread angle (30° for standard 60° threads)
- µc = collar/nut face friction coefficient
- rc = mean collar radius ≈ 1.25 × D/2 for standard hex nuts
For 60° threads (UNC/UNF/ISO metric): cos(30°) = 0.866
Bolt Grades and Strength
| Metric Grade | Property Class | Proof Strength (MPa) | Ultimate (MPa) | SAE/Imperial |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Low carbon | 4.6 | 225 | 400 | Grade 2 |
| Medium carbon | 5.8 | 420 | 520 | Grade 2 (higher) |
| High strength | 8.8 | 600 | 800 | Grade 5 |
| Alloy steel | 10.9 | 900 | 1000 | Grade 8 |
| High alloy | 12.9 | 1080 | 1200 | Grade 8 (higher) |
Preload Target
Typical preload is 75% of bolt proof load for permanent connections:
Tensile stress area for metric bolts (ISO 898-1):
| Diameter | Pitch | Stress Area (mm²) |
|---|---|---|
| M8 | 1.25 | 39.7 |
| M10 | 1.5 | 64.1 |
| M12 | 1.75 | 92.1 |
| M16 | 2.0 | 167 |
| M20 | 2.5 | 258 |
| M24 | 3.0 | 369 |
| M30 | 3.5 | 580 |
| M36 | 4.0 | 840 |
Standard Torque Values (Metric, K=0.20 Lubricated)
| Bolt | 8.8 (N·m) | 10.9 (N·m) | 12.9 (N·m) |
|---|---|---|---|
| M8 | 25 | 37 | 44 |
| M10 | 49 | 73 | 88 |
| M12 | 85 | 127 | 152 |
| M16 | 210 | 315 | 378 |
| M20 | 425 | 630 | 755 |
| M24 | 725 | 1100 | 1320 |
| M30 | 1450 | 2100 | 2520 |
| M36 | 2530 | 3780 | 4540 |
Worked Example — M20 Grade 8.8
- M20 bolt, stress area As = 258 mm²
- 8.8 grade proof strength = 600 MPa
- Target F = 0.75 × 600 × 258 = 116,100 N = 116 kN
- Lubricated (K = 0.20): T = 0.20 × 0.020 × 116,000 = 464 N·m
- Dry (K = 0.30): T = 0.30 × 0.020 × 116,000 = 696 N·m
Same bolt, same preload, different torque values depending on K.
Tightening Methods
| Method | Accuracy | Cost | Applications |
|---|---|---|---|
| Torque wrench | ±25-35% | Low | General purpose |
| Calibrated torque wrench | ±15-25% | Medium | Most industrial |
| Turn-of-nut (angle) | ±10-15% | Low | Structural bolts |
| Hydraulic tensioner | ±5-10% | High | Critical flanges, large bolts |
| Bolt elongation (ultrasonic) | ±1-5% | Very high | Turbines, pressure vessels |
| Direct tension indicator (DTI) | ±10% | Medium | Structural steel |
Tightening Sequence (Flanges)
For flange joints, tighten bolts in a crisscross (star) pattern in at least three passes:
- First pass: 30% of target torque
- Second pass: 60% of target torque
- Third pass: 100% of target torque
- Optional final pass: clockwise around flange at 100%
This ensures even gasket compression and prevents flange bowing or leaks. Follow ASME PCC-1 guidelines.
Bolt Torque for Pressure Vessels and Flanges
For ASME B16.5 flange joints per ASME PCC-1:
- Calculate required gasket seating stress (from gasket manufacturer)
- Determine total bolt load to seat gasket and resist internal pressure
- Select torque that achieves target bolt stress
- Apply in crisscross pattern per PCC-1
For spiral-wound gaskets: target gasket stress ≈ 50-70 MPa (7-10 ksi), which sets the bolt load.
Bolt Relaxation and Re-Torquing
- Embedding: Bolts and gaskets relax in the first 24 hours; re-torque hot bolts after heat cycle
- Gasket creep: Spiral wound and compressed fiber gaskets relax; some specs require re-torquing
- Thermal effects: Different thermal expansion between bolt and flange changes preload
Common Mistakes
- Using same torque value regardless of lubrication
- Not calibrating torque wrenches (should be calibrated annually)
- Tightening in a circle instead of crisscross pattern
- Using impact wrenches for final torque (no control, causes overload)
- Ignoring bolt material differences (Grade 5 vs Grade 8 torque values differ)
- Overlooking thread condition (dirty/rusty threads = high friction = low preload)
- Mixing bolt grades in same joint (uneven load sharing)
Summary
Use T = K × D × F for bolt torque, with K = 0.20 lubricated or K = 0.30 dry. Target preload at 75% of proof load. Standard metric torque tables assume K = 0.20 — adjust for actual lubrication. Friction dominates (80-90% of torque), so control surface condition and lubrication. Always tighten in crisscross pattern per ASME PCC-1 for flanges. For critical joints (pressure vessels, large flanges), use hydraulic tensioners or ultrasonic measurement instead of torque-only control.